<< Previous || Next
>>
Appendix 3: Project Listing
This section summarises the various case studies that have been
considered. This should not be taken as any kind of authoritative
assessment nor as a directory of good practice, although there is
plenty of such practice. Relevant information has been summarised
to save space and may be incomplete: the limited resources available
to this project did not allow for further work on this data.
Rathcoole Estate, Belfast
Contact: Roy McPherson, Special Projects Branch,
Northern Ireland Housing Executive, 3rd Floor, The Housing Centre, Adelaide
Street, Belfast BT2 8PB
Catalyst: Major problems of violence and lawlessness. Apathy
and despondency amongst residents, little feeling of togetherness
anonymous place to live. Housing Executive embarked on big
renovation programme of the estate, including the demolition of some
towers. Housing managers and existing residents association made
an effort to forge a new start.
Focus: Resident consultation, security, greening. Made it a safer,
softer place to live.
Security: CCTV, fence, 24 hour security guards. Invested in proper
training for security guards. This has made a big impact on level of
violence.
Greening: estate had big expanse of impersonal green space. It
was costing a lot just for the Housing Executive to keep it neat and
tidy wanted to do something more constructive with the money
being spent on cutting the grass. Used landscape architect and consulted
residents community garden, fruit bushes, somewhere to sit out
and meet neighbours, aimed to design it in a way that cultivated ownership.
Residents involvement: Consultation process. Lottery funded visit
to England to get ideas from projects there. Residents clear about what
they wanted in terms of design, colours, etc. Community association
involved in planning development of community garden.
Supporting organisations: Main push seems to have some from Housing
Executive professionals on the ground. Real effort at consultation and
letting residents preferences steer the revamping of the towers. Actively
went out to engage with residents door-knocking etc. Still found
it difficult to generate interest.
Burrowes Street Estate, Walsall.
Six 8 storey towers.
Contact: Terry Eadis, Burrowes Street TMC, The Management
and Resource Centre, Burrowes Street, Walsall WS2 8NN
Initiative came from existing tenants group, which decided to
embark on the road to becoming a TMO. Galvanised by opportunities for
City Challenge and Estate Action funding environment.
Relies on the committed few. 6-7 are active day-to-day.
Long process, importance of training. Asserting whos boss, whos
the customer LA and contractors used to sorting all jobs out
between themselves. The TMO has now assumed much of the maintenance
budget and deals with contractors direct. TMO employs staff. Manages
finances has been much more successful at getting more repairs
done within the budget than was the LA. Funding for Management
and Resource Centre, lease it out for seminars etc.
Importance of having a fairly settled, stable population on the estate.
TMO built houses to encourage balance of ages and family types. Virtuous
circle now with families of the residents wanting to move on to the
estate.
Taken over grounds maintenance. Installed fences for privacy. Divided
some space up into garden plots. Footpaths, benches. Britain in Bloom
Award.
Social activities reduce isolation: luncheon club for elderly, breakfast
club run by volunteers so earns some money for the estate.
Issue of furniture from voids. Offered to next tenants or goes to furniture
recycling / community transport project.
Holly Street, Dalston, London
Contact: Ken Gilmour, 16d Grange Court, 355
Queensbridge Road, Dalston, London E8 3JD; and Stuart Woodin, Community
Regeneration Consultant, 66 Geoffrey Road, London SE4 1NT
Catalyst was regeneration initiative in the area which required community
involvement and consultation with tenants. Issue-based sub-groups (including
older residents concerns) formed out of which grew a community
trust the Queensbridge Trust. Part of this process was consultation
and decisions about housing. Originally residents wanted all towers
demolished but it emerged that the older tenants liked tower block living
safety, spacious and one needed to be kept to meet housing
density requirements.
Residents v. involved in design issues. Insisted on 24 hour concierge.
Office space and new shops at sub mezzanine level. Whole project very
expensive: c.£10m for 119 units. Other problems allocation
policies, quality of buildings, immediate surroundings, not good for
families with children.
Queensbridge Trust was the spur for lots of initiatives: strong focus
on training and community businesses cleaning, minor repairs,
landscaping, concierge. Winning new contracts from the landlord. Job
Link by local people for local people. Sports and Community Centre with
IT suite and a community café. Designed central square, secure
play areas. Residents room in the tower for informal socialising.
Five towers, Camden, London
Contact: Harry Mayers, Energy Conservation
and Solar Centre, Unit 325/6, 30 Great Guildford Street, London SE1
0HS
Focus: Big regeneration package for 5 towers in Camden. One of
8 DETR pilots using PFI for social housing. Private sector awarded Facilities
Management Contracts the deal is that they undertake big
capital improvement projects early on and then get to sell services
to residents for the following however many years. Penalised if performance
judged below par by the tenants. Testing out strength of this accountability
mechanism.
This big project has descended on the residents who are now getting
up to speed or at least the two from each block who are on residents
steering committee. Previously tenants activity was minor
repair issues within each block. Tenants committee has decided it wants
to broaden out the agenda to take in training, employment, mothers and
toddlers, etc. Only about 6 months into the process. 18 months of consultation
to follow, then 3 years capital works.
Beckton, Docklands, London E6
Contact: Ian Muir, East Thames Housing Association
Focus: Tower converted into foyer and move on accommodation
for young people. Projects with community radio and cyber café.
Blakenhall, Wolverhampton.
Contact: Helen Blakey, Focus Housing
A Tower of 134 units with some big problems. HA took it over from LA,
spent £3m on physical improvements, concierge, security etc. But
there is no demand. Tenancies usually last 6-12 months with transient
young people. Only 30% been there longer than 3 years. Means loss of
rental income, arrears, voids.
Their solution: short term -reduce rents to attract low earners
as opposed to benefit claimants (from £70 down to £50),
and market it accordingly. Longer term as partners in neighbourhood
management model with LA , SRB, New Deal for Communities to try
to turn round the area over a 5-10 year period. Tackle the tower block
problem as part of a bigger regeneration effort.
Appletree Court, Salford
Contact: Betty Burton, Appletree Court, Salford
Catalyst: tenants association formed in 1988. Main purpose
was social. Over the years this forum for social interaction also gave
residents a forum to talk about concerns, notably repairs, maintenance
and management; and they began to take more of a concerted interest
in these matters and take that to the LA. By 1993 were looking at forming
a tenant management company. They took the plunge on the basis that
wed be able to sort it out ourselves instead of having to
wait for the council (i.e. repairs). 1996 teamed up with Tony
Milroy of the Arid Lands Initiative and begun to transform the grounds.
Focus: TMC took responsibility for maintenance, repairs, lettings and
ground maintenance. The Urban Oasis began to emerge involving successive
projects in the grounds. The starting point was the erection of a fence
to provide security. A café and a vandal-proof conservatory have
also been built.
Resident involvement: the various projects have been at the initiative
of the residents.
Supporting organisations: Arid Lands Initiative, the probation service.
Lambeth, London
Contact: Dan Blythe, Hyde Housing Association
Catalyst: Five year programme worth approximately £16 million
under the Estate Renewal Challenge Fund. Residents balloted over stock
transfer.
Focus: Physical improvements security including concierge
to cover three towers, new kitchens and bathrooms, central heating,
windows, ventilation. London Electricity upgrading transformers. Hyde
Plus concept of support for the community involving employment
and training apprentice scheme and building a new a community
centre with creche facilities.
Residents involvement: consultation.
Supporting organisations: Hyde Housing Association
Dickens House, Kilburn, London
Contact: Keith Marsh, London Electricity
Focus: Energy-saving through promoting energy
awareness amongst residents. The objective is to reduce demand on the
network and avoid having to upgrade cables and transformers, etc.
Residents involvement: Applying information gleaned from awareness-raising
campaign to change their energy use habits.
Rockingham Estate, Southwark, London
Contact: Sam Teague, Chaucer Environmental
Forum, c/o REPA, 10 Dickens Square, off Harper Road, London SE1 4JL
Catalyst: community visioning and Planning for Real event associated
with local SRB programme. Residents expressed an interest in starting
gardening, composting and recycling schemes.
Focus: composting scheme to be extended to recycling in due course.
The estate is a mix of high and low rise, and when ready the compost
will be available for use on peoples gardens. Two tower blocks
are participating. Six large collection bins have been placed around
the estate, about half of them are being used. There is also a window
box project which has about 40% take up in the towers. This was promoted
through the local free paper, posters and leaflets through peoples
doors.
Residents involvement: identified the project as desirable,
practical participation in implementation. One resident is cultivating
a do-it-yourself allotment plot at the base of his/her tower.
Supporting organisations: Chaucer Environmental Forum, part of
Chaucer Community Regeneration Partnership.
Milton Gardens, Hackney, London
Contact: Evonne Spyrou, Finsbury Park Community
Trust, Parkgate House, 306 Seven Sisters Road, London N4 2AG
A pilot recycling scheme launched by Waste Not Recycling.
Focus: doorstep collection recycling scheme covering high-rise,
low-rise and street housing, the high-rise being Milton Gardens. The
scheme has not been developed for various regions but has allowed the
following lessons to be learned regarding recycling collections in tower
blocks:
The compact way that tower blocks are laid out makes collecting
and sorting the waste easier and quicker. Being indoors is a big advantage.
Gaining access can be a problem. Access needs to be by arrangement,
and a good relationship with the caretaker is important.
The high turnover of residents that is a feature of some tower
blocks presents a major obstacle to running a recycling scheme.
There is a danger that if the waste is not collected on the appointed
day, it will be interfered with and spread around the block.
Residents involvement: changed habits and raised awareness.
Supporting organisations: Waste Not Recycling, London Borough
of Hackney.
Wentworth Tower, Upperthorpe Estate, Sheffield
This estate has a box based door-to-door recycling scheme
for the 48 unit tower block by Wastestream Systems, a non-profit recycling
collection contractor. The scheme was initiated in March 1999. Research
in November 1999 recorded a diversion rate of 31%. Scheme results will
be compared on costs and performance basis with similar systems elsewhere
in Sheffield, Newham, and Lambeth through research by the Safe neighbourhoods
Unit.
The Groves, Hartcliffe, Bristol
Contact: Mr K Williams, 27 Oak House, The Groves,
Hartcliffe, Bristol BS13 0RY
Catalyst: tenants association lobbied council for improvements.
In response the local authority secured Estate Action funding for a
five year programme to redevelop five tower blocks.
Focus: physical improvements landscaping, cladding, windows.
Tenants centre for the estate and a community room in each block
Residents involvement: campaigned for the improvements,
represented on the interview panel that selected architects.
Supporting organisations: Bristol City Council.
Edmonton Green Estate, Haringey
Contact: Phyllidia Culpin, Green Horizons Office,
South Mall, Edmonton Shopping Centre, Edmonton, London N9
Catalyst: stock transfer to housing association followed by refurbishment.
Focus: physical improvements concierge, kitchens and bathrooms,
lifts, heating. Capacity-building community board established
with membership divided in thirds between residents, the local authority,
and the housing association. Training programme for tenants members
including governance, business planning, and financial management.
Residents involvement: consulted and balloted about key
issues of stock transfer and redevelopment. Preference of more elderly
residents to remain in the high rise blocks led to three towers being
retained (a shopping centre is housed at the bottom of the blocks).
Supporting organisations: Metropolitan Housing Association, London
Borough of Haringey.
Dunbar House and William Saville House, Kilburn, London
Contact: John Drake, New Leaf, Lanmore House,
370-386 High Rd., Wembley HA9 6AX
Catalyst: approach made to residents by New Leaf, a local environmental
organisation. New Leaf wanted to replicate the Salford Urban Oasis concept.
Focus: creating a community garden and mini-allotments. In the
relationship between New Leaf and the residents it was acknowledged
that the state of repair of the blocks was a more important issue for
residents; but, presented with the opportunity, they were keen to work
with New Leaf on this project to improve their grounds.
Residents involvement: participating in Planning for Real
event, visit to Salford Urban Oasis project, interviewing landscape
architects, and appointment of part-time gardener. Residents are also
being offered mini-allotment plots.
St Peters Court, Lowestoft
Contact: Daphne Richardson, 51 St Peters
Court, Chapel Street, Lowestoft, Suffolk NR32 1QH
Catalyst: tenants association already in existence. The councils
decision to cover the flat roof with a sloping roof removed the facility
of somewhere to sit outside in the summer. Residents decided to do something
with the grounds instead.
Focus: landscaping including raised gardens and a lawn. Other
initiatives in the block include regular social activities in the community
room, outings, and a weekly community shop. 102 out of 125 residents
are pensioners.
Residents involvement: ideas and projects discussed and
carried out by residents, including applying for a grant for the garden.
Supporting organisations: community projects grant from Shell
Better Britain Campaign.
Blackbird Leys Estate, Oxford
Contact: Jenny Clamp, Blackbird Leys Tower
Blocks Association, 38 Windrush Tower, Blackbird Leys, Oxford OX4 5HY
Catalyst: newly formed tenants association invited senior council
officer to one of their meetings, the outcome being a survey of problems
in the blocks. This led to action.
Focus: physical improvements tackling asbestos, damp and
condition of windows
Residents involvement: organising themselves into a group
to campaign for improvements. The tenants group won a TPAS Participation
into Practice Award in 1997.
Supporting organisations: Oxford City Council, TPAS.
Alder Court, Wolverhampton
Focus: refurbishment. In the mid 1990s Sanctuary Housing
Association bought the tower at nil cost in return for undertaking to
raise £3 million for physical improvements including cladding
and a 24 hour concierge.
Northwood Tower, London Borough of Waltham Forest
Focus: physical improvements in the early 1990s
including structural strengthening, new roof, combined heat and power
system, controlled entry and new kitchens. Cost £5.1million. Experimented
with a rolling method of keeping most tenants in the block
while refurbishment underway.
Residents involvement: questionnaire (showing heating and
security as two prime concerns); public meetings; 10-member tenant design
team consulted in detail on choices.
Supporting organisations: London Borough of Waltham Forest, Hunt
Thompson Associates
Kingsbridge Court, Manchester
Contact: Michael Culver, Flat 7, Kingsbridge Court,
Kingsbridge Road, Harpurhey, Manchester M9 5SW
Focus: fencing off part of the grounds and creating a barbeque
area, producing a greeting pack for new tenants.
Residents involvement: projects are the residents
initiative.
Supporting organisations: Manchester City Council
Platt Court and Worsley Court, Manchester
Contact: Mr G.E.Windsor, Secretary of
Worsley and Platt Court Tenants Association, 15 Worsley Court,
Rusholme, Manchester M14 5LU.
Focus: the two blocks cater for the over-55s. They have a
social room which hosts regular coffee mornings and bingo. The tenants
association organises outings. There is a high standard of security
and a good caretaker. The blocks have had intensive work to improve
their heating. This has entailed the installation of a group heating
system, pitched roofs, and new radiators and double glazing.
Residents involvement: tenants association liaises with
the council and organises social activities.
Supporting organisations: Manchester City Council energy-efficiency
unit financed the improvements through a bid for Private Finance Initiative
funding.
Artillery Court, Manchester
Contact: Hillary Hackin, 47 Artillery Court, Wadeson
Road, Brunswick, Manchester M139TU
Focus: tenants are frustrated that on occasion flats are still allocated
to younger people, and they are pressing the council to follow a policy
of only letting flats in the block to people over 40. The council has
put up a fence around the block, and residents are asking that the parking
area be separated from the grounds. They have taken part in tree-planting,
and individual residents are encouraging their neighbours to have plant
pots on their balconies. The block is involved in a project to establish
an urban orchard on the estate. It possesses a communal laundry facility
in the basement.
Residents involvement: individuals take part in activities,
but only a couple of people are involved in running the tenants association.
Supporting organisations: CTAC (Community Technical Aid Centre)
and Manchester City Council.
Cundiff Court, Manchester
Contact: Mary Wolstencroft, 19 Cundiff Court,
Levenshulme, Manchester M19 3HZ
Focus: the block has a community room which is the focus of social
activities. Residents have created a communal garden around the base
of their block. It is secure, with a fence all the way round, and has
wheelchair access.
Residents involvement: the block caters for middle-aged
to elderly people. The garden project was the residents initiative
they fundraised for it, and now take responsibility for its maintenance.